Best Mystery Movies

Best Mystery Movies on Filmtally, ranked by rating and popularity. See where to watch and track what you want to see.

The X-Files: I Want to Believe (2008)

Moon of the Wolf (1972)

Sword of God (2020)

Midnight in the Switchgrass (2021)

Inner Demons (2014)

The Tunnel (2011)

Return to Cabin by the Lake (2001)

Woman of Desire (1994)

Conspiracy (2008)

Hidden Face (2024)

Cellphone (2024)

Last Passenger (2013)

Domestic Disturbance (2001)

The Nude Bomb (1980)

I Think We're Alone Now (2018)

Heaven's Prisoners (1996)

The Final Conflict (1981)

Irresistible (2006)

You Belong to Me (2008)

Slam Dance (1987)

The Last Fashion Show (2011)

Slow Burn (2005)

The American Side (2016)

Frank & Lola (2016)

The Woods (2006)

Psycho IV: The Beginning (1990)

The List (2007)

Share (2019)

Perfect Stranger (2007)

Don't Look Back (2009)

Alone at Night (2023)

The Last Seven (2010)

Chemical Wedding (2008)

Don McKay (2009)

House of Spoils (2024)

Mayday (2021)

Dark Tower (1987)

Shelby Oaks (2025)

Christina's House (2000)

The Wind (2018)

It Lives Inside (2023)

Bug (1975)

Acolytes (2009)

Needle (2010)

Another Simple Favor (2025)

The Little Stranger (2018)

Evil Angel (2009)

The Sound (2017)

Blessed (2004)

The Dark (2005)

Deep Water (2022)

Thriller (2018)

Beneath (2007)

Crowsnest (2012)

The Driftless Area (2015)

Ring Around the Rosie (2006)

Bermuda Island (2023)

Abduction (2011)

Ghost House (2017)

The Resident (2011)